Frustrations

I’m the president of a human rights group on campus. I usually really enjoy my role in the organization, but over the past three weeks, I’ve had to do two things that I feel bad about.

I had to reprimand two of my officers. About four weeks ago, our group decided to screen the movie Blood Diamond, and use the screening as an opportunity to educate attendees about, what else, blood diamonds. Well, about one day before the screening date, two of my officers announced that they hadn’t put up the advertising fliers, and would not be making it to the screening. That was ok, because the room we’d reserved wasn’t so great for a movie anyway, so I agreed to reschedule it to this Saturday.

I sent out an officer-wide e-mail, assigning everybody various tasks. These same two officers not only didn’t do what they were told, they didn’t check in with me, and only revealed that they hadn’t done their job when I pressed them. I frantically called up my treasurer, who ended up filliing out some crucial paperwork so that the screening could go on as planned (a job that one of the irresponsible officers was supposed to do). They apologized with the excuse that they were too busy to do their job. Everyone is busy, and the least they could have done was tell me that they weren’t going to complete their responsiblities so that I could have assigned them to someone else.

And so, I threatened to fire them. This really sucks for our group, because it’s small and struggling, and needs all the help it can get. However, I have to have committed officers, or else how can we expect to get anything done.

My second problem has to do with Falun Gong. About two weeks ago, I was contacted by a grad student who told me he was a Chinese human rights activist. I was really interested and asked him to stop by our weekly meeting so that he could tell everyone about the types of things he does. Well, I should have asked if he was a Falun Gong member, but it didn’t cross my mind until it was too late.

I understand that horrible things have happened to the Falun Gong in China. Horrible, horrible things. However, it’s almost impossible to figure out the truth when dealing with them, because they (and the CCP) exaggerate and lie about facts and figures.

The grad student gave a propaganda rich presentation, and, despite the human rights abuses that Falun Gong had suffered, as well as the revolting images in his Powerpoint presentation, I had to frequently hold in my laughter at some of the ridiculous things he was saying.

I see striking similarities between the Li Hongzhi’s personality cult and Mao’s.

Anyway, this grad student wanted me and my group to sponsor a human rights lecture by some Falun Gong officials on campus. This presented me with a dilemma. On one hand, I should help them in my capacity as president of a human rights organization. On the other, doing so could get me banned in China. The grad student was getting Falun Gong and local press to cover the event, and I had no desire to have my name associated with it.

I haven’t spent all this time studying China and Chinese to get banned from China.

Is this selfish on my part? I don’t think so. For one, I don’t see what good this lecture could do. Moreover, I feel that I’ll be in a better capacity to help the people of China if I’m not banned.

Still, I can’t help but feel annoyed and disappointed every time I feel the effect of the Anaconda in the Chandelier.

7 Responses to “Frustrations”

  1. While China’s human rights record should be examined, IMHO human rights can only be defended with facts, not sensational “spin”.

    And just a fair warning to not offend (piss off) the FLG people. They have a track record of intimidating critics.

    I should know, as my objection to some of the things you noticed have garnered me a “Chinese spy” hat by Falun Gong’s media Epoch Times.

  2. You’re right, absolutely horrendous things have happened and continue to happen to Falun Gong practitioners in China. There is no need to fabricate facts or figures. The widespread torture of Falun Gong practitioners carried out by the Chinese communist party (CCP) has been documented by many independent organisations such as the United Nations and Amnesty International.

    Canadian human rights lawyers David Matas and David Kilgour have also carried an independent investigation with overwhelming evidence to suggest widespread, systematic and ongoing organ harvesting from living Falun Gong practitioners in China.

    However what has been documented is but the tip of the iceberg.

    That student was simply trying to explain to you the severity of this persecution and the extent of the CCP’s crimes against these good, innocent people. He is trying to save these people’s lives..

    It is also wrong of you to refer to Falun Gong as a “personality cult” and mention Mr. Li in the same breath as that murderer Mao. That is an absolutely groundless and improper statement.

    I hope you will reconsider and take part in the lecture on human rights.

    Here are some third party links that you can take a look at:

    United Nations Report:
    http://flghrwg.net/index.php?option=content&task=category&id=111&sectionid=8&Itemid=

    Amnesty International:
    http://www.amnesty.org.nz/web/pages/home.nsf/dd5cab6801f1723585256474005327c8/83fba691f912206bcc2571d3001824ed!OpenDocument

    Report into organ harvesting:
    http://www.organharvestinvestigation.net/

    Thanks.

  3. Jason,
    Your so-called ‘third-party’ links seem to be all written by Falun Gong.

    I’m not disputing Falun Gong’s persecution, I’m merely skeptical of the facts, figures, and articles that Falun Gong presents.

    Still, thank you for your comments, and know that I’ll continue to keep an open mind about the Falun Gong movement while I’m learning more about what’s really going on.

  4. The Falun Gong allegation David Matas’ promoting has been discredited by multiple undercover investigations.

    US government and Chinese dissident investigations:

    1) http://www.zonaeuropa.com/20060806_1.htm

    http://www.cicus.org/news/newsdetail.php?id=6492

    2) http://usinfo.state.gov/xarchives/display.html?p=washfile-english&y=2006&m=April&x=20060416141157uhyggep0.5443231&t=livefeeds/wf-latest.html

    http://www.usembassy.it/pdf/other/RL33437.pdf (section CRS-7)

    3) http://crc.gov.my/clinicalTrial/documents/Proposal/TCM_Stroke%20TrialProtocol%20synopsis.pdf (page 3)

    As you can see, the hospital Falun Gong accused is partly owned by a Malaysian health care company and is subject to oversight beyond Chinese authority.

  5. Charles, thanks for the links. I’m glad to see that my skepticism was entirely warranted. By the way, the lecture on campus was given by David Matas. I didn’t attend, however.

  6. discussions of Falun Gong frequently become polarised in this way. The links Liu presented are very much different from the question of organ harvesting and the report by Kilgour and Matas. Matas just got the Tarnopolsky award from the Canadian Bar Association, Amnesty’s chief lawyer in Canada, some other roles I am sure–do these kinds of people make things up? He’s a well known lawyer. David Kilgour was several decades in the Canadian parliament, lawyer, foreign minister for asia-pacific for several years. These people take themselves seriously, and they are seriously presenting their report. They are not Falun Gong practitioners.

    Please just look into their report and judge for yourself. I don’t know if the facts and figures are made up or not. I think Falun Gong is only claiming about 3000 confirmed deaths by torture–is that so hard to believe? Even if you didn’t listen to Falun Gong one bit and just looked at the UN, Amnesty, US State Dept., and other independent bodies you’d have a very strong case. Actually, I look up now and notice that none of those links was written by Falun Gong at all. One of them was hosted on a Falun Gong website.

    Please look past your prejudice and look at the facts. Don’t think you’ve got this whole thing figured out. It doesn’t matter if you think Falun Gong is a dumb idea–that is way beside the point. Be sure not to confuse the issues. Just imagine they are some other prisoners of conscience getting murdered, and just look at the evidence as it stands in itself–this may require some personal sincerity. Since you are interested in human rights, it ought not be a problem.

    I can give you a stack of links, none of them Falun Gong, which would prove beyond all doubt to any reasonable person what is going on. You can email me if you like. The http://organharvestinvestigation.net/ should be enough, though.

  7. Sorry last thing, just on a personal note. I feel sorry that you have developed negative feelings toward Falun Gong/Falun Gong practitioners. I feel that I am unable to meaningful engage or address that in this kind of communication method. On a very basic level though, I have found it no more than a set of free teachings. When people say bad things about Falun Gong or raise suspicions about it, this point seems to be overlooked–whatever the opinion, on a really basic level, Falun Gong is guilty of nothing. Personally, all I (how do I italicise?) have tried to do is practice quietly–and now, tell people about the nasty persecution in China, against those who also only want to practice quietly…

Leave a Reply